Apr 26, 2017 - Citronella collars are a great option for owners seeking to put an end to their dog's constant barking. Check out five of the best options here.
A barking dog will receive a mild shock around the neck, this is usually uncomfortable to the hound. These devices need to be properly set so the shock is neither too mild (it won’t bother your pooch and he won’t stop barking) nor too strong (the pain can make your dog aggressive or fearful). This type of collar is usually the most effective because the shock is usually uncomfortable to all dogs, unlike citronella and high-frequency sounds.
The way citronella dog collars work is by sending a misty citronella puff near your dog’s nose. The spray both distracts your dog from barking and punishes him. The punishment is simply the bad scent they smell. Unlike dogs, humans do not find the smell of Citronella unpleasant, on the contrary some people use this scent for aromatherapy.
Although citronella is safe to use even around young kids, ingesting large quantities may be harmful and if accidentally sprayed into the eye, it can cause irritation.
Is the Citronella Dog Collar A Safer Alternative to Electric Shock?
PetSafe Gentle Spray Bark Control Pet Training System | Petco
The aim of our study was to investigate whether citronella-spray collars offer a humane alternative to electric-shock collars to reduce the barking of domestic dogs. The Aboistop collar was applied to seven dogs with problematic barking behaviour by the dogs' owners in a series of case studies concurrently run. Vocalisation of the dogs was recorded in the problem context under baseline conditions, inactive collar conditions, and active collar conditions. The Aboistop collar was effective at reducing problem vocalization for only three of seven dogs and appeared to be most effective for dogs whose problem barking had developed more recently. The collar may be more humane than other punishment methods, but it did produce stress reactions which varied in severity across the dogs. Clinical Relevance. In our study, the collar was applied by the dogs' owners in order to test whether the collar would be effective when used by members of the public. While the results here are preliminary, they suggest that the collar may be effective for some dogs, but not for others, when applied by dog owners for the treatment of problem vocalisation. Further research is required to determine whether the collar could be effective when administered by a trained professional.We had two main aims in addition to measuring the efficacy of mild punishment delivered via citronella collars in reducing vocalization of domestic dogs. Firstly, we set out to measure the longer-term effectiveness of citronella collars, by measuring vocalization across multiple treatment sessions, and 3 months after the end of the treatment phase. We sought to obtain a more objective measurement of barking than in previous research, by tape recording the dogs' vocalizations. Secondly, we monitored the dogs for any signs of distress while using the collars.For humane reasons, dog owners are likely to prefer less intensely punishing solutions to their dogs' barking behaviour. In one study, dog owners reported a preference for citronella-, or lemon-spray collars, which deliver a spray of citronella when a microphone detects barking, over shock collars, because they perceived them as more humane . No significant difference was found in mean plasma-cortisol values (a stress indicator) between dogs that wore shock versus lemon-spray collars , and it is not clear whether lemon-spray collars result in fewer pain and stress reactions than shock collars.The Aboistop collar contains a laryngophone which activates a spray jet via a selector. According to the manufacturer, the spray is activated by a 95 dB-level bark. However, A-weighted testing in the psychophysics laboratory of the University of Auckland indicated that the spray was triggered by an 80 dB sound. The collar is powered by a 6 V battery which lasts for an estimated 1000 sprays. A reservoir contained within the casing of the collar, and which sits on the dog's throat, holds approximately 20 sprays of citronella. Upon activation, a single spray of citronella is forced upward towards the dog's mouth and nose upon each separate bark. Thus, a continually barking dog will experience multiple sprays. The canister makes a pressure release sound similar to a can of fly spray when activated.